"What? You must be joking!" - this could have been the reaction of an average Mumbaikar, on being informed that his city is the rudest, according to the much talked-about Reader's Digest survey. Well, I had a similar reaction as well. At the very outset, let me confess that I am not even an inch of a Mumbaikar and I have only visited the city on two occasions (and that too, aeons ago). Still, on those two occasions, the little experience that I had of being in the city, there was no hint whatsoever of its people being the "rudest". To be fair to the people behind the survey, a city and its people do change with time. But, I can surely vouch for the fact that Mumbai can never go as far as becoming the rudest city in the country. Besides my own experience, I have had many feedbacks from reliable sources to support my statement. And, I being the peace-loving Bengali, always thought there are quite a few other cities that are far ruder - our capital city being the first and foremost here. New Delhi, the symbol of "India Shining", sadly, does not have a big heart. If any person lay dying or injured on the road, what would be the reaction of an average "Dilliwala"? - "Chal Chhod Yaar, Marne de". The example used here might be a tad extreme, but it is has been used only to show the extent of the mechanical life our capital city leads. On the other hand, I also dare to cock a snook at my own city - Kolkata. This city, with its language as sweet as the ubiquitous rosogolla, is not really what it seems. Otherwise, why would any young passenger on a bus be reluctant and at times, quite irritated, to vacate his seat to his aged counterpart? Also, the countless autorickshaws that have sprouted up from nowhere, tell a similar story. Ask any officegoer about his daily experience with an "autowalla" and you will understand. Aren't these things more realistic indicators on the "rude-o-meter" devised by Reader's Digest, instead of people picking up others' papers in a queue? And then, how could this distinguished magazine forget the chawls of Mumbai? These are perhaps the best symbol of social interaction and bonding in today's fast-paced world, prompting academic institutes of repute to build case studies on them. Which chawl-dweller will say his next-door neighbour is ruder than the rudest?
So, its time that such survey-designers became a little bit wise!

